Gandalf vs. Dumbledore
Vote then reply down below
Vote then reply down below
This is a read-only archive of the Opticraft Community forums (2010–2022), preserved in October 2026. Posting, logins and registration are closed.
Started by Caanite., March 20, 2014, 09:03:17 AM
Total Members Voted: 10
Voting closed: March 27, 2014, 09:03:17 AM
Who do you think is better? Gandalf or Dumbledore
But the big question is why the heck are people voting for lil' old dumbledore, when everyone knows about "you shall not pass"?
Caanite.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 280
-
-
- Location: New Zealand
khoiboy51
-
- Full Member
- Posts: 191
- Official SMP Trusted!
-
-
- Location: AUSSIE
Dumbledore because I have no idea who the hell Gandolf is
Wone
- Self-proclaimed Grammar Nazi Colonel
-
- Full Member
- Posts: 224
- Be courteous or GTFO
-
-
- Location: Malaya
Quote from: khoiboy51 on March 20, 2014, 11:03:07 AMtheyellowguy1234's forum profile picture is Gandalf.
Dumbledore because I have no idea who the hell Gandolf is
daniblue182
- Mayor of Xanadu
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 475
- 'All this time?' 'Always'
-
-
- Location: A muggles house in narnia
SalsaInABowl
- AKA SalsaOnTheFloor
-
- Champion Member
- Posts: 1,539
- Retired. Find me on Steam or IG.
-
I barely know who they are but I pick Dumbledore because it has something to do with my last username that people would joke about. I still don't get the whole Snape joke shit to this day but whatever.
Caanite.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 280
-
-
- Location: New Zealand
Quote from: khoiboy51 on March 20, 2014, 11:03:07 AMMaybe you should try to spell Gandalf correctly. And watch Lord of the Rings.
Dumbledore because I have no idea who the hell Gandolf is
SJ321987
-
- Full Member
- Posts: 118
- hii
-
-
- Location: Maryland
tiggy26668
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 464
-
Dumbledore is just a wizard, a powerful wizard, but just a wizard none the less....
whereas Gandalf is an immortal being known as a Maiar......
Gandalf literally doesn't give two shits about Dumbledore because he can just sit around waiting for him to die.
Gandalf
Maiar
Dumbledore
whereas Gandalf is an immortal being known as a Maiar......
Gandalf literally doesn't give two shits about Dumbledore because he can just sit around waiting for him to die.
Gandalf
Maiar
Dumbledore
Caanite.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 280
-
-
- Location: New Zealand
Quote from: tiggy26668 on March 20, 2014, 10:59:36 PMI would like to say that while I agree with most of your statements, Gandalf can die. If Maiar were immortal then the battle between the Balrog and Gandalf would last forever. Also not to mention that Sauron couldn't be defeated and Saruman couldn't die. Ageless would be a better word though. But I think Gandalf is better than Dumbledore in every way but pure magical power (Gandalf hardly uses his magic to directly interfere in the war). And to those who have seen the movies, yes I know Gandalf came back to life but it was not his doing rather than one of the Middle-earth Gods.
Dumbledore is just a wizard, a powerful wizard, but just a wizard none the less....
whereas Gandalf is an immortal being known as a Maiar......
Gandalf literally doesn't give two shits about Dumbledore because he can just sit around waiting for him to die.
Gandalf
Maiar
Dumbledore
square_skull
-
- Full Member
- Posts: 175
- Heeeeere's Skully!
-
-
- Location: New Zealand
Quote from: Caanite. on March 21, 2014, 01:26:03 AMCaanite/theyellowguy, you speak the truth...Quote from: tiggy26668 link=topic19357.msg190449#msg190449 date=1395356376I would like to say that while I agree with most of your statements, Gandalf can die. If Maiar were immortal then the battle between the Balrog and Gandalf would last forever. Also not to mention that Sauron couldn't be defeated and Saruman couldn't die. Ageless would be a better word though. But I think Gandalf is better than Dumbledore in every way but pure magical power (Gandalf hardly uses his magic to directly interfere in the war). And to those who have seen the movies, yes I know Gandalf came back to life but it was not his doing rather than one of the Middle-earth Gods.
Dumbledore is just a wizard, a powerful wizard, but just a wizard none the less....
whereas Gandalf is an immortal being known as a Maiar......
Gandalf literally doesn't give two shits about Dumbledore because he can just sit around waiting for him to die.
Gandalf
Maiar
Dumbledore
But the big question is why the heck are people voting for lil' old dumbledore, when everyone knows about "you shall not pass"?
Caanite.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 280
-
-
- Location: New Zealand
Quote from: square_skull on March 21, 2014, 11:12:20 PMYep, I ask the same question lolQuote from: Caanite. on March 21, 2014, 01:26:03 AMCaanite/theyellowguy, you speak the truth...Quote from: tiggy26668 link=topic19357.msg190449#msg190449 date=1395356376I would like to say that while I agree with most of your statements, Gandalf can die. If Maiar were immortal then the battle between the Balrog and Gandalf would last forever. Also not to mention that Sauron couldn't be defeated and Saruman couldn't die. Ageless would be a better word though. But I think Gandalf is better than Dumbledore in every way but pure magical power (Gandalf hardly uses his magic to directly interfere in the war). And to those who have seen the movies, yes I know Gandalf came back to life but it was not his doing rather than one of the Middle-earth Gods.
Dumbledore is just a wizard, a powerful wizard, but just a wizard none the less....
whereas Gandalf is an immortal being known as a Maiar......
Gandalf literally doesn't give two shits about Dumbledore because he can just sit around waiting for him to die.
Gandalf
Maiar
Dumbledore
But the big question is why the heck are people voting for lil' old dumbledore, when everyone knows about "you shall not pass"?
Wone
- Self-proclaimed Grammar Nazi Colonel
-
- Full Member
- Posts: 224
- Be courteous or GTFO
-
-
- Location: Malaya
Why do you even make this topic, Caanite?
We know that dumb old door shall not pass Gandalf.
How pointless.
We know that dumb old door shall not pass Gandalf.
How pointless.
Duinis
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts: 284
- Arghblarglarghlpoop.
-
-
YOU
SHALL NOT
PASS