Discussion forum > Suggestions
Reform for top_voter rewards
cschurz:
i wouldn't call top voter an incentive, i would call it a reward to those who are dedicated.
nobody mentioned the access to a second /home? that's a pretty useful incentive imo.
but i agree, a single diamond really isn't all too great - some ideas i've had:
- get a random block (or item) out of some random set of usually difficult to obtain blocks/ores
- have a list of voter items that progressively gets better - each time you vote, you get the next item in the list
- voting milestones - every x votes (20, 50, 100) you get a slightly better reward (enchanted items maybe?) along with your normal vote diamond
bantam2:
--- Quote from: cschurz on December 19, 2012, 12:48:31 pm ---i wouldn't call top voter an incentive, i would call it a reward to those who are dedicated.
nobody mentioned the access to a second /home? that's a pretty useful incentive imo.
but i agree, a single diamond really isn't all too great - some ideas i've had:
- get a random block (or item) out of some random set of usually difficult to obtain blocks/ores
- have a list of voter items that progressively gets better - each time you vote, you get the next item in the list
- voting milestones - every x votes (20, 50, 100) you get a slightly better reward (enchanted items maybe?) along with your normal vote diamond
--- End quote ---
I like the idea of a random block. Introducing the milestones or a list of items could just cause some more problems. If you implement those now, someone who joins 2 months from now will be making another topic like this and complain that other people are getting better voting rewards than them.
Like you said deject, 2 homes is a really good perk that people seem to overlook. In my opinion, the voting system is perfectly fine.
cschurz:
--- Quote from: bantam2 on December 19, 2012, 02:59:53 pm ---
--- Quote from: cschurz on December 19, 2012, 12:48:31 pm ---i wouldn't call top voter an incentive, i would call it a reward to those who are dedicated.
nobody mentioned the access to a second /home? that's a pretty useful incentive imo.
but i agree, a single diamond really isn't all too great - some ideas i've had:
- get a random block (or item) out of some random set of usually difficult to obtain blocks/ores
- have a list of voter items that progressively gets better - each time you vote, you get the next item in the list
- voting milestones - every x votes (20, 50, 100) you get a slightly better reward (enchanted items maybe?) along with your normal vote diamond
--- End quote ---
I like the idea of a random block. Introducing the milestones or a list of items could just cause some more problems. If you implement those now, someone who joins 2 months from now will be making another topic like this and complain that other people are getting better voting rewards than them.
Like you said deject, 2 homes is a really good perk that people seem to overlook. In my opinion, the voting system is perfectly fine.
--- End quote ---
that wouldn't happen how i imagined it: 50 votes maybe = 1 enchanted pick. then when you get another 50 votes, you get the same pick (maybe randomized enchantments).
though it wouldn't be a bad thing to have the vote rewards get better over time. it adds a sense of permanence to the server - if people feel like they've put in some irreplaceable effort/time into this server (and are being adequately compensated by vote rewards) then they are less likely to just pack up and go somewhere else.
SalsaInABowl:
How about every ten votes we get a diamond block?
cschurz:
--- Quote from: SalsaInABowl on December 19, 2012, 03:13:27 pm ---How about every ten votes we get a diamond block?
--- End quote ---
bombarding people with diamonds is not the answer :)
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version