Opticraft Community
Discussion forum => Applications => Creative => Archives => Rejected => Topic started by: dougtato on January 03, 2015, 07:50:45 pm
-
Ingame name: douglas_anthony
Join date: Late August / Early September
Briefly describe all your creations: The three creations I am using for my Crafter application are my World Trade Center, my
Washington National Cathedral, and my treehouse.
What world/s are the creations on: All three are in Builder.
Links to screenshots of the creation: http://imgur.com/a/IifaP
Extra (Anything else you want to mention): I better get this or I will freak out. Also, I think my treehouse is the best of the builds listed.
-
Good luck Doug! :) :)
-
yas
-
I wish you the best of luck doug :D <3 you king of potatos you :3
-<3Wolfie
-
Sorry I didn't get first comment, but good luck anyway! You always inspired me to work harder when I build, and because of that, I get better results. Good luck and I want to see your name in bold purple!
-
Good luck! If any senior staff see this, the Cathedral is the most detailed and amazing structure I have seen in my 3 years of Minecraft experience. And I have seen some of the best builds, yet still this is the best.
-20JPorter
-
I love the tree house!
-
Best of luck doug! You have put a lot of time into this and you deserve it.
-
Good luck, you definitely deserve it :)
-
Good luck Doug!!
-
Why do none of the builds have interiors?
-
I like the classic throwback choice
-
Why do none of the builds have interiors?
^
-
Why do none of the builds have interiors?
Because interiors aren't necessary for a build to look amazing, clearly demonstrated by douglas.
-
Interior is every bit as important as exterior. In most cases, it's where the most detail is.
-
I think the design of a build needing more exterior or interior design is a matter of opinion. Who are we to judge a person's build because we want to see it that way? If the original builder chose not to include as much interior while instead focusing more on exterior, then they had a good reason to. It is their build and it is their vision.
Each build is a representation of the artistic imagination of the builder. Interior is not always a necessary aspect to a build though it does help create a more realistic and heavily detailed world for the viewers of the build. It's more something to please the viewers at this point though, since this is large scale.
When building on a large scale such as this, interior is no longer the focus. It's mostly exterior. It's all about accuracy, beauty and symmetry. It's about leaving you absolutely breathless.
The reason I see interior being forced into builds nowadays is because no one is impressed by anything anymore. We have seen all kinds of builds already and its just like "ya cool...but give me more detail because I want it". And so it became sort of a unanimous decision that now EVERY build must have both interior and exterior. Which is a wrong way of judgement. This is a creative freebuild server. We should be able to express ourselves however we see fit and not simply to appease others' standards. If we decide there will be less interior design than exterior then that is our choice. And ya I get it. He is making an application to become crafter, something the higher staff will be judging. So, in the end, its really their decisions and their rules. However, I would hope there is a fairer judging standard than just "hurr durr no interior. only exterior. no crafter for u ".
Rant complete. Feel free to bash it.
Good luck, doug.
-
You are correct, a builder can build any which way he prefers, however, a crafter should be well rounded.
-
I think the design of a build needing more exterior or interior design is a matter of opinion. Who are we to judge a person's build because we want to see it that way? If the original builder chose not to include as much interior while instead focusing more on exterior, then they had a good reason to. It is their build and it is their vision.
Each build is a representation of the artistic imagination of the builder. Interior is not always a necessary aspect to a build though it does help create a more realistic and heavily detailed world for the viewers of the build. It's more something to please the viewers at this point though, since this is large scale.
When building on a large scale such as this, interior is no longer the focus. It's mostly exterior. It's all about accuracy, beauty and symmetry. It's about leaving you absolutely breathless.
The reason I see interior being forced into builds nowadays is because no one is impressed by anything anymore. We have seen all kinds of builds already and its just like "ya cool...but give me more detail because I want it". And so it became sort of a unanimous decision that now EVERY build must have both interior and exterior. Which is a wrong way of judgement. This is a creative freebuild server. We should be able to express ourselves however we see fit and not simply to appease others' standards. If we decide there will be less interior design than exterior then that is our choice. And ya I get it. He is making an application to become crafter, something the higher staff will be judging. So, in the end, its really their decisions and their rules. However, I would hope there is a fairer judging standard than just "hurr durr no interior. only exterior. no crafter for u ".
Rant complete. Feel free to bash it.
Good luck, doug.
Your argument makes sense and doesn't make sense at the same time. It makes sense that people build what they want and how they want, that's fine, but he is going for our rank. Our rank that we came up with has our standards, especially when it comes to the highest building rank there is.
Now the problem with this is it creates a kind of "build for the rank" mentality that we don't want. This server isn't supposed to be about suffering through a build to get a rank, it is supposed to be about building because you love to build and if you happen to pick up a few ranks along the way, cool.
-
I think the design of a build needing more exterior or interior design is a matter of opinion. Who are we to judge a person's build because we want to see it that way? If the original builder chose not to include as much interior while instead focusing more on exterior, then they had a good reason to. It is their build and it is their vision.
Each build is a representation of the artistic imagination of the builder. Interior is not always a necessary aspect to a build though it does help create a more realistic and heavily detailed world for the viewers of the build. It's more something to please the viewers at this point though, since this is large scale.
When building on a large scale such as this, interior is no longer the focus. It's mostly exterior. It's all about accuracy, beauty and symmetry. It's about leaving you absolutely breathless.
The reason I see interior being forced into builds nowadays is because no one is impressed by anything anymore. We have seen all kinds of builds already and its just like "ya cool...but give me more detail because I want it". And so it became sort of a unanimous decision that now EVERY build must have both interior and exterior. Which is a wrong way of judgement. This is a creative freebuild server. We should be able to express ourselves however we see fit and not simply to appease others' standards. If we decide there will be less interior design than exterior then that is our choice. And ya I get it. He is making an application to become crafter, something the higher staff will be judging. So, in the end, its really their decisions and their rules. However, I would hope there is a fairer judging standard than just "hurr durr no interior. only exterior. no crafter for u ".
Rant complete. Feel free to bash it.
Good luck, doug.
Well said. Best of luck to you doug!
-
Your argument makes sense and doesn't make sense at the same time. It makes sense that people build what they want and how they want, that's fine, but he is going for our rank. Our rank that we came up with has our standards, especially when it comes to the highest building rank there is.
I'm not arguing that he is applying for a rank based on your standards. That's true and I know that.
There is just this expectation to worry about interior just as much as exterior, which isn't the right message. A builder should feel comfortable with whatever they intend to create and not feel forced to add in details they don't deem necessary. Some builds are just meant to be interpreted "as a whole" rather than "look inside my incredibly realistic rendering of the inside of the Taj Mahal".
But I can see why such expectations exist for the higher building ranks of Builder and Crafter. I was just hoping that the lack of an aspect such as interior design isn't something that will heavily affect the final judgement of the builder's abilities. If there is a lack of one aspect, I'd hope the other aspects are just weighed a bit heavier than they would have if that aspect was there. So like lack of interior=slightly harder judgement on creativity, symmetry, concept, beauty, realistic factor, etc etc. But I am sure there probably is a much more complicated ranking process for Crafter than there is for Builder.
This server isn't supposed to be about suffering through a build to get a rank, it is supposed to be about building because you love to build and if you happen to pick up a few ranks along the way, cool.
I absolutely 100% agree with this sentiment. Build freely as you please and accomplish rank ups as a side incentive.
-
gl dougtato
-
Hello Staff and Fellow Members,
Nick, I understand entirely that a builder is going for your "rank" but may I ask to what standards you refer? If
"Extremely impressive builds, renowned for quality" is your standard than I fail to see all the controversy over Douglas's build, merely standing next them to evokes a sense of awe and accomplishment. If you're going to enforce a standard make a clear category you're rating an individuals building potential/build by.
I suggest a written set of categories available to all, for reference, these categories would be the cornerstone in which each build is measured and would avoid this mess entirely, each category would have a rating of 1-10 and in order to get CRAFTER there would need to be minimum total that is averaged between each Owner/Admins score sheet. For Example; The categories used could be:
WOW Factor!! (When you see this build does it's presence/appearance amaze you)
SIZE (Speaks for itself)
CREATIVITY (It's it a cookie cutter build or is it true inspiration)
EFFORT (How much time and dedication did it take to complete the build)
COMPLETION (Amount of Project Completed)
DETAIL (Is everything that can be done with respect to the build done in order to breathe life into it
RESPONSIBILITY (This applies to his maturity to handle the /kick function and should be considered)
Those listed should be totaled up and averaged together across the people judging it , and if the score exceeds the minimum threshold of lets say 55/70 then BOOM! crafter. I totally respect all of you making this judgement and how you're worried about how it will affect Doug, but I think I believe part of the problem here is none truly has set a standard and a many of us feel the process needs more oversight and standardization.
If we can advance the server together we'll have a much more pleasant experience overall <3 because in the end, the server would be a lonely place without it's members.
-
I suggest a written set of categories available to all, for reference, these categories would be the cornerstone in which each build is measured and would avoid this mess entirely.
What mess are you referring to? As far as I can see, there is no problem that needs attention. We are all just commenting on the application, nothing more. The owners and admins already have their ways of judging. You already need promission from one of them to even apply, so by that you already know you are either there or close.
And as previously stated, players are not to think they are to build to a specific standard, so a rubric would be counterproductive in that aspect. For some players it might be nice, for others, it may have a negative effect.
However, this is a topic for creative suggestions, as to not get this application off topic.
-
Hello Staff and Fellow Members,
Nick, I understand entirely that a builder is going for your "rank" but may I ask to what standards you refer? If
"Extremely impressive builds, renowned for quality" is your standard than I fail to see all the controversy over Douglas's build, merely standing next them to evokes a sense of awe and accomplishment. If you're going to enforce a standard make a clear category you're rating an individuals building potential/build by.
I suggest a written set of categories available to all, for reference, these categories would be the cornerstone in which each build is measured and would avoid this mess entirely, each category would have a rating of 1-10 and in order to get CRAFTER there would need to be minimum total that is averaged between each Owner/Admins score sheet. For Example; The categories used could be:
WOW Factor!! (When you see this build does it's presence/appearance amaze you)
SIZE (Speaks for itself)
CREATIVITY (It's it a cookie cutter build or is it true inspiration)
EFFORT (How much time and dedication did it take to complete the build)
COMPLETION (Amount of Project Completed)
DETAIL (Is everything that can be done with respect to the build done in order to breathe life into it
RESPONSIBILITY (This applies to his maturity to handle the /kick function and should be considered)
Those listed should be totaled up and averaged together across the people judging it , and if the score exceeds the minimum threshold of lets say 55/70 then BOOM! crafter. I totally respect all of you making this judgement and how you're worried about how it will affect Doug, but I think I believe part of the problem here is none truly has set a standard and a many of us feel the process needs more oversight and standardization.
If we can advance the server together we'll have a much more pleasant experience overall <3 because in the end, the server would be a lonely place without it's members.
You misunderstand, there is no controversy over dougs builds. I was simply responding to a statement that DJ made in a general sense. I was not talking about any app in particular it just happened to be in dougs app which is probably not the place for it. sorry.
And mime, you cant standardize a process to judge creative builds because each one is uniquely different.
-
Well Judging only on that treehouse I would say "Congrats"
-
Back on Classic, if you were trying to apply for Crafter and your builds (this is applying to buildings and architecture) didn't have an interior, then the admins probably wouldn't have even given you permission to apply. And this was in the days of only having 44 items (37 blocks, 5 plants, and water/lava) to work with and a height limit of little over 90 blocks high.
Now with what builders have now with Creative mode and huge worlds, it should really be no surprise what we're expecting. Especially for Crafter.
The WTC is given leeway since every floor would be pretty much the same thing.
-
The treehouse will defiantly be the make-or-break for this one! Good Luck doug :)
-
Rejected due to nothing being done for this app